The Course Rankings

Town Guides / Florida

The Naples Golf Guide

A golfer walking a fairway
A golfer walking a fairway. Photo: PattayaPatrol, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Naples has more golf holes per capita than almost anywhere in America, a statistic that sounds like a chamber of commerce line until you drive it: gated golf communities stacked one after another, most of them private, in a town built substantially around the game. The visitor's problem in Naples is not finding golf. It is finding golf you are allowed to play. The good news is that the public and resort bench punches well above the usual standard for a private heavy town, and it includes the course the locals name when you ask where they would play with one round left: Old Corkscrew, out in Estero, an uncompromising Jack Nicklaus test with no houses on it at all.

Build the trip around that scarcity logic. Book the hard to get rounds first, let the resort courses fill the frame, and save the hardest golf for when your group is fully warmed up.

The Resort Frame: Tiburon and Naples Grande

Tiburon Golf Club is the tournament address. The Gold Course, a Greg Norman design from 1998 at the Ritz-Carlton, hosts the tour in December in its current Grant Thornton Invitational era and also carries the LPGA CME Group Tour Championship, which makes it one of the rare resort courses that ends two professional seasons. Its signatures are manufactured but effective: stacked sod wall bunkers and coquina waste areas, trouble with a distinct visual language. Play the Gold as your tournament round, mid trip, and concede the resort frame around it. The golf inside the ropes is real.

Play the Black Course before it. Norman's second course on the property, from 2001, is tighter and more tree covered than the Gold, routed through pine and cypress strands while the Gold takes the tournament duty. Black is where resort and member play lives day to day, and as a sequencing matter it is the right rehearsal: narrower corridors, more emphasis on position, a quieter round that gets your driving honest before the Gold's waste areas start keeping score. Groups that reverse the order tend to find Black an anticlimax. Groups that play it first find it a course in its own right.

Naples Grande Golf Club is the flexible piece. A Rees Jones design from 2000, routed around lakes in central Naples and known for its par 3 holes over water, it is the upscale resort round that fits an arrival day or a morning tied to the beach resort it serves. Access runs through the Naples Grande Beach Resort, which makes it the easiest quality round in town to arrange and, in a private heavy market, that convenience has genuine value. Play it early. It calibrates Florida golf for your group: flat ground, water in play, Jones bunkering, greens that reward the aerial game most visitors brought with them.

Old Corkscrew Is the Point

Old Corkscrew Golf Club is the round this trip exists for, and it should be scheduled last and protected. Nicklaus built it in 2007 in Estero, inside an Audubon certified natural setting named for the Corkscrew Swamp country of southwest Florida, and the defining choice is what is not there: no residential housing on the course, none, in a region where golf is usually a real estate delivery system. Water and preserve shape most holes, the corridors feel genuinely wild, and the test is regularly ranked among the best public courses in southwest Florida for the simple reason that it asks championship questions in a setting that has nothing to do with a development.

It is also hard, and our ordering argument follows from that. Played early, Old Corkscrew humbles a group into a defensive crouch for the rest of the trip. Played last, after Tiburon has tuned your driving and Naples Grande has settled your iron play, it becomes what it should be: the exam you prepared for, and the round everybody argues about on the drive back. Locals call it the hard pick and mean it as praise. Budget for the premium dynamic pricing, accept a ball or two lost to the preserve, and do not schedule anything important for immediately afterward. You will be later than you think, and you will not care.

The mistake in Naples is assuming the private depth of the town is available to you, or burning days trying to route around it. It is not, and you do not need it. The second mistake is the opposite snobbery: dismissing Tiburon as resort product and playing only Old Corkscrew twice. The Gold's tournament test is a different and legitimate pleasure.

Winter and early spring are peak season, with the tour in December as the ceremonial start, and prices across the resort bench sit at premium Naples levels. Summer is the value window and a real one, traded against heat, humidity, and the afternoon storm cycle: play early, hydrate, and treat the afternoons as the Gulf's time rather than yours.

Leave Old Corkscrew at the end of the day, preserve on both sides and no rooftops anywhere, and the Naples paradox resolves itself. The town with a golf course behind every gate turns out to have saved its best public round for the place with no gates at all.

Reader responses are open. Please cite a specific hole, a price, or a round you have played.