The Course Rankings

Town Rankings / North Carolina

The Best Golf Courses in Hendersonville

A leading golf course in North Carolina
A leading golf course in North Carolina. Photo: Dan Perry from Atlanta, USA, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Hendersonville runs on a simple proposition: flat enough land in the valley to build on, mountains close enough to look at, and a population of retirees who moved to western North Carolina intending to play a lot of golf. By the hook for this list, the town claims more golf per retiree than anywhere else in these mountains. Spend a week here in October and the claim stops sounding like a boast. The tee sheets are full of people who planned their lives around exactly this.

The three courses that matter are all private, which is the catch, and they cover three distinct eras. A Tom Fazio from the height of his mountain period. A Donald Ross from the 1930s. A Joe Lee in Flat Rock from the early 1980s. We rank the golf first, and in Hendersonville that gives the modern Fazio the edge over the classic Ross, a call some readers will argue with on the drive home.

1Champion Hills Club

Tom Fazio built Champion Hills in 1988, right when his name had become the default answer for upscale mountain golf in the Carolinas, and the course has stayed on North Carolina top 100 lists ever since. That durability matters. Plenty of 1980s private courses aged into subdivisions with some holes attached. Champion Hills kept its standing because the golf, routed through mountain laurel and elevation, keeps asking questions that a prettier but softer course would stop asking by the fifth hole.

Fazio in the mountains is a particular style. The holes feel carved rather than placed, the greens sit in natural looking bowls and shelves, and the walk or ride keeps reminding you that the land came first and the golf had to negotiate with it. Members joining a mountain club in 1988 wanted exactly that drama. They still get it.

The concession is that Fazio's hand can feel heavy if you prefer your architecture quiet. Against a Ross in the same town, Champion Hills will always be the louder course, and loud is not a synonym for better.

It takes No. 1 here anyway, on the strength of the overall test and its sustained place in state rankings. In a town built for people who play three or four times a week, the course that holds interest the longest wins, and that is Champion Hills.

2Hendersonville Country Club

The counterargument wears plus fours. Hendersonville Country Club is a Donald Ross design from 1932, classic Ross mountain golf from the years when Ross and his associates were drawing courses all over the North Carolina hills, and it has the virtues that never go out of fashion: greens that punish the wrong side, a routing that fits its ground, and a scale that feels human.

If this ranking were architecture in a vacuum, Ross might well take the top spot. His Hendersonville work comes from the same mind that built the state's most beloved courses, and a restoration minded membership can keep a course like this honest for another ninety years.

Why second, then. Two reasons, stated plainly. The Fazio course is the bigger, more complete modern test, and Ross in the mountains was often working quickly across many commissions, not every one of them a masterwork on the level of his Sandhills courses. This is a very good Ross. It is not Pinehurst No. 2 wearing a sweater.

Private, like everything on this list, with the usual barrier that implies. If an invitation to either of the top two arrived, take the Ross for the history lesson and the Fazio for the examination. You will not regret either answer.

3Kenmure Country Club

Kenmure sits in Flat Rock, the old summer colony town next door to Hendersonville, and Joe Lee designed the course in 1982. Lee was the professional's professional of that era, a designer whose courses working golfers tend to enjoy more than panels tend to praise, and Kenmure fits that description: Henderson County mountain golf, private, established, and built for a membership that plays it constantly.

Third place is not a dismissal. Kenmure predates Champion Hills and held the area's private golf fort through the years before Fazio arrived with a bigger budget and a bigger reputation. Golfers who value playability over spectacle often prefer Lee's restraint, and there is a real case that Kenmure is the best everyday course of the three for a mid handicap member.

The case does not quite carry a ranking that scores the golf first. Against a top 100 regular and a genuine Ross, the Lee course is the bronze medal in a three club town, in a valley where the season runs long, the air stays cooler than the Piedmont below, and the retirees on the first tee at 8 a.m. have already won the only ranking they care about.

Reader responses are open. Please cite a specific hole, a price, or a round you have played.