The Course Rankings

Town Rankings / Idaho

The Best Golf Courses in Sun Valley

A leading golf course in Idaho
A leading golf course in Idaho. Photo: Locke Cole, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Sun Valley was America's first ski resort, a place invented by a railroad to sell winter, and golf here has always been the summer understudy that turned out to be better than anyone expected. The Wood River Valley runs narrow and green between dry mountains, Bald Mountain watches everything, and the golf season is short enough that locals treat a September round like found money.

Four courses make the bench, two of them the resort's, two of them the valley's own. The ranking rewards the golf first, then the day, then access, and Sun Valley scrambles all three, because the resort courses come with the resort's theater while the local courses in Ketchum come with something rarer in a famous valley: the feeling that golf belongs to the people who live here.

1Sun Valley Resort Trail Creek Course

Trail Creek is the valley's championship course, a Robert Trent Jones Jr. design at the resort, and it carries the top spot on the strength of being the only complete examination on this list. Jones worked the course along Trail Creek with the mountains as gallery, and the round keeps changing scale on you, tight where the creek and the trees close in, open where the valley floor lets a swing breathe. Resort courses often coast on setting. This one uses the setting as architecture, which is a different and better thing.

The concession is the resort frame around it. You are a guest at a famous hotel property, with the pricing and polish that implies, and purists who like their golf unadorned will find the whole Sun Valley production a little pleased with itself. Fair. The golf underneath the production is still the best in the valley, and it has been the valley's standard for long enough that the other courses on this list are, in a sense, replies to it.

2Elkhorn Golf Club

Elkhorn is the valley's semi private counterweight, a course with resort bones and a local membership, set in the Elkhorn hills south of the main resort ground. It ranks second because it splits the difference this valley keeps negotiating: better golf than the town courses, better access than a pure resort round, and a quieter day than Trail Creek delivers in high season. Golfers who summer in the valley tend to land here, and that kind of revealed preference is evidence.

The honest knock is that second place in Sun Valley is partly a scheduling award. Elkhorn does not beat Trail Creek hole for hole and does not try to. What it offers is the valley's golf life as residents actually live it, which on a ranking that counts the day as well as the design is worth exactly one spot below the top.

3Sun Valley Resort White Clouds Course

White Clouds is a nine on the hill above the resort with Bald Mountain in your face, and it is the most purely pleasurable golf in the valley if pleasure is measured in views per hole. Nine hole courses live or die on whether the holes justify the trip, and these do, on elevation and panorama alone. It is the round you play on arrival day, or with somebody who plays twice a year, and it never feels like the consolation prize it looks like on paper.

Third because nine holes is nine holes. A ranking has to count the missing half, and White Clouds cannot give you the full day's examination Trail Creek can. But we will concede the counterargument in full: on a clear evening, with Baldy turning colors and the valley going quiet, this little course on the hill produces the moment people actually describe when they get home.

4Bigwood Golf Course Ketchum

Bigwood is Ketchum's own public golf, the locals' course in the town that does the valley's actual living, and it closes the list the way a town course should: open, affordable by valley standards, and unbothered by the resort up the road. It plays along the Big Wood River country that gives it its name, in the shadow of the same mountains, at a fraction of the resort price and none of the resort ceremony.

Fourth on golf, first on citizenship. The gap between Bigwood and the resort courses is real and we will not blur it. But a valley where the public course survives, busy and unembarrassed, next door to America's first destination ski resort, is a valley that has its priorities in an order this ranking respects.

The season ends early here and everyone knows it, which is why the last warm week in the Wood River Valley plays like a holiday nobody declared.

Reader responses are open. Please cite a specific hole, a price, or a round you have played.