The Course Rankings

Town Rankings / West Virginia

The Best Golf Courses in White Sulphur Springs

A leading golf course in West Virginia
A leading golf course in West Virginia. Photo: HARRY W. McCORMACK (TEABERRYEAGLE), CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

White Sulphur Springs is a small town in the West Virginia mountains built around one very large hotel. The Greenbrier has been taking guests since long before golf mattered, and then golf arrived in a serious way. Sam Snead, who grew up in this part of the world, was the pro here for decades. That alone would give the place a claim. The courses give it three.

This is resort golf in the old American sense: stay at the hotel, play the courses attached to it, argue about them at dinner. We rank the golf first, because a pretty hotel cannot save a dull course, and then the day around it. All three anchors belong to the same resort, so the argument here is really about order, and about which round you protect if the trip gets cut short.

1The Old White at The Greenbrier

Old White is the reason this town is on any golf map. The record states it plainly: a Macdonald and Raynor design from 1914, and later the host of the PGA Tour's Greenbrier Classic. Charles Blair Macdonald and Seth Raynor built template golf, holes modeled on famous British originals and adapted to the ground in front of them. You feel that logic as you play. Angles matter. The safe side is not always the smart side, and the greens ask questions that a century of resort play has not dulled.

Tour history helps, but it is not the ranking. Plenty of Tour stops are forgettable. Old White holds up because the architecture underneath the event is older, stranger, and more interesting than most of what the Tour usually plays. A 1914 Macdonald-Raynor that still hosts modern professionals and still makes resort guests think is doing two jobs at once, and doing both well.

The concession: resort pricing and resort pace come with it, and if you want solitude you will not find it here in peak season. Template holes can also divide people. Some golfers love seeing the ideas repeated and refined. Others want every hole to look like nothing they have seen before.

Play it first anyway. If you play one round in White Sulphur Springs, this is the round. Everything else at the resort is a supporting argument.

2The Greenbrier Course

The second spot goes to the Greenbrier Course, the resort's other serious test. In a three-course resort the middle course often gets treated as filler, the round you schedule between the famous one and the easy one. That undersells what a resort actually needs, which is a second course good enough that a four-day stay does not feel like repeats.

Its job in the order is different from Old White's job. Old White is the history and the architecture lesson. This is the round where a group settles in, plays a full test without the museum feeling, and decides whether the trip was worth the drive into the mountains. It does that job well enough to hold off the third course, which is built for a different purpose.

The honest knock is comparison. Any course sharing a resort with a 1914 Macdonald-Raynor starts the argument a lap down, and no amount of good conditioning closes that gap.

3The Meadows Course at The Greenbrier

The Meadows is the gentler option, and there is no shame in that role. Every multi-course resort needs a course for the mixed group, the second round of the day, the guest who plays twice a year and still wants a real afternoon. That is what sits third here.

It loses on ceiling, not on usefulness. If Old White is the course you tell stories about, the Meadows is the course that keeps a trip from falling apart when half the foursome is tired, sore, or outmatched. Conceded, gladly: on a couples trip or a corporate outing, this might be the round people actually enjoy most.

Just do not confuse most enjoyable for best. The ranking rewards the golf first, and by that measure the order above the Meadows is clear.

Evening comes down fast in these mountains, and the hotel lights up, and the argument at dinner is always the same one. Nobody argues about whether to have played Old White. They argue about whether anything else in West Virginia is close.

Reader responses are open. Please cite a specific hole, a price, or a round you have played.